![](https://cos-cdn.shuashuati.com/pipixue-web/2020-1231-2005-12/ti_inject-812ce.png)
Consider the following argument: GARY: The existence of abduction survivors proves the existence of extraterrestrials. MARY: How do we know the alleged survivors aren’t making their stories up? GARY: They can’t have made the whole thing up; as you know, abduction victims are notoriously incapable of making up stories about their abduction. In this argument, Gary is